Table of Contents
Case Study: The Andrew Street Mob by Brian Marais
Design brief: Create a book design and production method to enable an author to publish a personal memoir.
Constraints: The Andrew Street Mob was not designed to be a commercial project, so the economics of the production had to be strictly monitored.
Raw material: Author Brian Marais submitted an unedited manuscript of 227,000 words and the desire to have a book that looked and read well. The book tells the author’s firsthand account of growing up amid a group of 40 or more kids in Johannesburg, South Africa in the 1950s.
Production problem: Digital printing and print on demand make books like The Andrew Street Mob possible. Without this technology very few books of this nature would be published, since the cost would be prohibitive.
But the nature of the production also presents challenges. The very long manuscript could conceivably create a book of 700 pages or more depending on the size, layout and typography.
Unfortunately, digital printers charge by the page, while publishers can’t get away with pricing by the page. A 700 page softcover book at Lightning Source will cost $10.00 each to print. That doesn’t leave a lot of room for a profit, let alone a wholesale discount.
Challenge: Create a book that can be handled and read, that’s economical to produce, and that minimizes the cost to print as much as possible.
Solutions and Compromises
Chapter opening - click to enlarge.
In the end it became clear that the publication would be more or less as a personal memoir. This decision allowed the author to move forward with a sympathetic editor in his family who would take care of polishing the manuscript.
Likewise, once the book was in proofs he found a friend to proofread and mark up the book before it went to press.
If he had been trying to create a commercial product, both of these important parts of the publishing process would have cost quite a bit more.
This spread has over 800 words but is still quite readable - click to enlarge
You’ll notice from the pages here that the spreads were not all vertically justified or combed through for typographic refinement. On a book this long, the amount of time needed to fine tune the whole thing would have been significant. This was another conscious choice, guided by the original discussions we had, to minimize the expense of the book production.
Click to enlarge
Conclusions
I’m a big fan of these kinds of books. Whenever I come across arguments about self-publishing that fall into black-vs-white arguments, I think of the many self-publishers I’ve known over the years and the many ways they have of publishing their books. Each one has their own reasons, their own ways of doing things. You can’t assume you know someone else’s aims or motivations.
The Andrew Street Mob is no exception. It’s a unique work that is destined to become a primary source for the experience of a particular time in a particular place. I don’t think we can have enough honest, direct and heartfelt testimonies to a specific human life. Our culture gains from the publication of these books, and I’m happy to have a hand in creating them.
Data
The Andrew Street Mob by Brian Marais on Amazon (affiliate link)
Marais Media International
ISBN: 978-0982673201
$19.95, 586 pages, 6″ x 9″ trade paperback
One of the best post I ever read.
Joel, I love Adobe Garamond Pro, did you state that this font helped to reduce the amount of pages in a book from 700 to 585? If so, is their a similar font which would help to increase the page count of a book?
Fonts have wider or narrower “set widths” and there are literally thousands of them. Using a service like Myfonts.com or Fontsquirrel.com will allow you to set a piece of sample text in different fonts to see the effect of each. That’s what I do.
Joel, I feel you’re a genius and you critique without being condescending. That said, I also like this type of book and the uniqueness of the theme of the story. For a book that is not designed to be a commercial project–the interior is beautiful and the exterior–although simple–is also very professional! But, a 700 page book that’s not designed to be a commercial project, by an unknown author, in a World that possesses the attention span of a gnat–seems destined to fail–unless published only for friends and family, am I right? If the book is not designed to be a commercial project, why worry about the profits?
Thanks, Rico. The book has achieved the goals the author/publisher set for it, so I see it as a success. Profit may or may not be one of the goals of a publication, but they all need to be taken into account when planning and executing a book like this one.
I always appreciate your blog, Joel, and referenced it on our blog yesterday. https://bit.ly/9pbX8d
I have a new client who wants to use LSI for a very long work of historical fiction, about 700 pages (and still editing). Any suggestions, in addition to Garamond, to reduce the page count and to make this project commercially feasible?
Hi Nan, I really like your site and the service you offer to authors. Thanks for linking to my blog, I really appreciate it.
Of course I don’t know the book, but as I indicated, an LSI production of a 700 page book is going to cost $10 wholesale. If you restrict sales to Amazon and other online retailers and go with a short (20%) discount, you could reasonably charge $20 for the book and walk away with a good profit on each copy.
There are a whole host of typographer’s “tricks” to manipulating page length, so I can’t really go into them in this comment, but perhaps this would make a good blog post.
If you have more detailed questions, Nan, please drop me an email and I’ll see if I can help. And thanks for reading!
Ahh, Adobe Garamond Pro. My all-time favourite font for fiction.
It makes my drunken prose look like Hemingway! :)
Chris,
Yeah, it’s elegant. How is your book coming along?
The book layout looks great, and the price is still affordable. It’s a win-win for everyone. I know about the issues with a larger book– my longest textbook is almost 750 pages, but the price point is much higher (like all textbooks) so I’m not as worried about the price adjusting higher on the page count. That being said, it’s an amazing job that you’ve done here– the entire project really looks great.
Thanks Christy!
Great advise for those working to self-publish, but also for those working with publishers of ALL types. DO NOT just accept what the publisher decides to do with your cover or your book design. Ask questions, offer ideas, make sure it all makes sense for the book style, genre, etc.
When I published my first book – Accidental Lessons the publisher’s artists’ initial idea was NOTHING what I envisioned and did not clearly represent the book. We worked together and came up with something that worked for them and me.
David B
Great point, David. Thanks for your input.
You might want to also mention that the trim size can have a huge effect on production costs, as certain sizes are much cheaper than others (try getting a price quote on a 6.5×8.5 or some other non-traditional size and you’ll see what I mean!). This depends, of course, on the printer you’re using, but the standard trim sizes are pretty universal because paper sheets come in specific sizes (parents) which are then cut down into the book’s size, and this is what a lot (most?) of the short-run self-publishing printers use. The more efficient use of your printing space, the cheaper and easier it is to print. Now, if you’re doing a very large print run on web-fed press, there’s less to worry about. It also makes it less of a headache for bookstores, who actually have to shelve the things.
I hope my info isn’t too out of date, but I haven’t used a short-run self-pub printer in a few years, and I know the tech has greatly advanced in that time…
Marcus, of course you are correct, and standard sizes offer the most cost efficient production. There is a difference, however with digital printers who offer only very specific sizes (see my recent post on How to Pick the Size of Your Book). This book was printed by Lightning Source, which categorizes and prices books as “small paperback” “large paperback” and within those ranges the prices are all the same. Still good advice, and thanks for your comment.
Ah, interesting. I thought I might be a tad out of touch with places like Lightning Source.
“Since cover design is largely positioning and packaging on commercial books…”
What does that mean?
J. Tillman,
It means that book covers are principally designed as packaging for a commercial product. And when we make a book look like it belongs in a specific genre, it’s serving the function of positioning the book in the potential buyer’s mind. So thrillers look like thrillers, not like devotionals or how-tos.